So the discussion is on. Question: Should I lean when I run? Here is my answer: If you don’t think leaning will help you, don’t. If you think leaning might help you, experience the effects first hand and draw your own conclusions.
Some “experts” suggest that it is not possible for gravity to propel you forward. This is very interesting since I have been using gravity in this way since I started ChiRunning® (“chee-running”, Chi Running) 5+ years ago. I don’t push, reach or pull – yet I move forward. How is it possible for the experts, draped in degrees from prestigious universities, to suggest that what I do is not possible? Perhaps:
- They have never actually tried it.
- They think they have tried it but could not get a sense for it.
- There is a gravitational void which cloaks anyone with a closed mind.
- They are applying a steady state hypothesis to the non-steady state application (chirp … more on this in a future post).
It seems rather embarrassing, but that may just be me. But in the end it really does not matter what they say or why. The bottom line is everyone has a choice, and hopefully that choice is based on a personal experience. Frankly, I rely on my own experience before I believe a textbook, an opinion, a study or someone else’s experiment. All of that is just information I consider as input to my own experiences.
So here is an experience for you:
- Stand up tall and lengthen the back of your neck. Soften your knees.
- Feel your feet flat on the ground.
- From the ankles, move your nose forward just 1-2″ by allowing your whole body to lean forward (as pictured below). Do not bend at the waist or allow you head/chin to jut forward.
Question: In this position, do you feel like you could fall forward? Most(*) people will answer yes, that they feel their weight come forward into their forefoot and a sense of wanting to take a step forward.
[*OK, so everyone I have coached through this simple exercise has agreed over the past 4+ years.]
So you feel a pull forward, but you are not moving forward. This must mean there is resistance or a brake somewhere. Question: Where do you sense a brake in your body? Most(*) people will say tension in the feet but there could also be tension anywhere to “hold onto” or resist the lean.
Question: What if you released that tension? What would happen? Ready, 3,2,1, release … most(*) people at this point take a step forward.
Next question: Did you have to push off to take the step? Most(*) people say no.
Next question: Did you have to think about bringing your foot forward to catch your step? Most(*) people again say no.
Next question: What if it were possible to turn your running into a series of these micro-falls and micro-catches such that you could run “without using your legs, (wait for it) … for propulsion”?
Now here is another experience for you:
- Stand up tall and lengthen the back of your neck.
- Feel your feet flat on the ground.
- Put your pointer fingers on your hip bones (as pictured below).
- From the hip joint, leaving your hips where they are, bend forward at the waist (as pictured).
Question: In this second position, do you feel like you could fall forward? Most(*) people will answer no – that they do not feel their weight come forward into their forefoot or a sense of wanting to take a step forward. They just report some extra effort to maintain this mis-aligned position.
Question: Why? Simple answer: gravity is not affecting you the same way it was before.
Now the experts will pick at the details and impress us with their book smarts, fancy terms, formulas, yada, yada, but here is how these experiences were explained very simply to me:
- Take a column.
- Tilt the column into gravity moving its center of mass in front of its contact point with the ground.
- The result is a forward force on the column. This is the same thing that happens to a falling tree, a unicyclist or with a young child’s instinct – to name just a few examples.
In the first experience, the body’s center of mass came forward … therefore a sense of a forward force. In the second experience, the body’s center of mass is still OVER the feet … therefore no forward force since gravity is still only resulting in a downward force.
So given my very high success rate at helping people feel these two experiences – and seeing the AHA moments on their faces, I can only assume that the experts have simply not tried it or that they don’t feel they need to try it. Neither situation provides credibility or deserves a moment of attention. But as above it really does not matter what happens in their world, it only matters what happens in your world.
Repeat Question: What if it were possible to turn your running into a series of micro-falls and micro-catches such that you could run “without using your legs, (wait for it again) … for propulsion”? What would that mean to your running, to your efficiency, to reducing stress that may lead to lack of enjoyment, discomfort or injury?
If you decide to try this, note that is does take practice to sense the position, stay relaxed and remain balanced. And that balance is possible through the coordination of the entire body. Isolating one ChiRunning concept, such as a subtle forward lean, is not advisable. Two resources for more information:
- Principles Summary: ChiRunning Simplified! Efficient and Injury Free Natural Running Technique
- Some background: Common Challenges, Lean, note you can only lean as much as you can relax; and it is much less lean than you think. Adding tension by leaning is not consistent with the main ChiRunning principles of alignment, relaxation and balance. In case it was not clear, bending at the waist is also not consistent with the ChiRunning principles.
Happy running, umm, I mean (subtle) falling. May the force be with, or more accurately may you allow the force of gravity to be with you …
05/10/12 Update: Part two is now posted which includes a physics analysis for your consideration: The Physics of ChiRunning, Lean … Analysis.
[See the Physics Resource Page for more information.]
Thoughts on this post? Leave your comment or question below and join the discussion …
David Stretanski is a holistic health, fitness and wellness coach and Certified ChiRunning®/ChiWalking® Instructor. For more information on David, please see his About Me, Contact page or his website at http://www.eChiFitness.com.
ChiRunning® and ChiWalking® are registered trademarks of ChiLiving, Inc.
Related Posts: If you enjoyed this post, you may also like ...
- ChiRunning Common Challenges, Lean Tweet One of the key ChiRunning® principles is to cooperate with external forces, using them to your advantage whenever possible. The external force of gravity can be used to your...
- The Physics of ChiRunning, Lean … Analysis Tweet This is the first of a few posts on the subject of physics in the running gait cycle. This post is a little long with some more technical content...
- Elements of ChiRunning Efficiency Tweet Recently … I was in an exchange online with another running coach in which I questioned the logic of essentially this statement, paraphrased here for clarity: “If a running...